Principal research fellow and former director of the middle east forum philadelphia, where he also edits the scholarly journal middle east quarterly. Karsh documents the fact that the socalled palestinian catastrophe is a self inflicted one. I consider this latest of karshs books, palestine betrayed, a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with the greatest seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of view indeed, any student of modern israel. Download pdf palestine betrayed free online new books. Sol schindler, washington times ephraim karshs palestine betrayed tells in rich detail the story of the fall of the british mandate and the rise of israel, going a long way towards doing justice to the history at hand. I consider this latest of karsh s books, palestine betrayed, a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with the greatest seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of view indeed, any student of modern israel will. Efraim karsh is professor and head of the middle east and mediterranean studies programme, kings college london. Karshs condescending and with a high probability, erroneous remarks that the new historians were totally unfamiliar with the arab world its language, culture, history, and politics and their condescending treatment of the palestinians as passive objects. This discipline has been dominated by what may be termed a culture of victimization. Karsh is an israelibritish historian, the founding director and emeritus professor of middle east and mediterranean studies at.
How have new historians distorted the israelpalestinian. Of course it was, by the british, the united states, france, the league of nations, the united nations, the remnants of the ottoman empire, all of the regional arab countries, and by certain elites and powerful of palestine itself. The palestine war 1948 essential histories by efraim karsh isbn. Feb 01, 2011 ephraim karshs palestine betrayed tells in rich detail the story of the fall of the british mandate and the rise of israel, going a long way towards doing justice to the history at hand. Seth frantzman, jerusalem post a thoroughly researched, sound historical account of the struggles that ensued between the jewish and arab communities when the british decided to leave palestine. The palestine war has been by far the most important military encounter in the history of the arabisraeli conflict. Professor of political science at barilan university. Schwartzwald in may 1961, the weekly london publication, the spectator, published an article entitled the other exodus, which sought to place responsibility for the palestine arab refugee problem squarely on israels shoulders. Efraim karsh beginsadat center for strategic studies. In palestine betrayed yale university press, 2010, efraim karsh, professor of middle east and mediterranean studies at kings college, london, refutes the revisionist accusation proffered by childers and the new historians, showing that what the archival materials actually prove is precisely the opposite. The author, erskine childers, an irish journalist, lamented the widespread and especially. Seth frantzman, jerusalem post new edition egypt on the brink from the rise of nasser. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Doctoral program in historymasters program in middle.
Efraim karsh the author is emeritus professor of middle east and mediterranean studies at kings college london, and a senior research associate at the beginsadat center for strategic studies, bar. Palestine betrayed by efraim karsh yale university press, london, 2010. Efraim karsh this article originally appeared in commentary magazine and the wall street journal on may 8th 2008. Next year finland will assume the eus rotating presidency, making foreign minister erkki tuomioja a player in the organizations middle eastern policy. Personal website professor of political studies, barilan university, since 20. Of course it was, by the british, the united states, france. In the arab capitals there were violent demonstrations. A history is a refutation of the commonly held notion that islamism developed as a reaction to western historical imperialism. Efraim karsh writes a learned account of the disputes in the middle east, from the mid 19th century till the arabisrael 1967 war and after, with a detailed blow by blow account of the 1947 partition and the 1948 arabisrael war and its consquences. About 2,400 years ago, herodotus told us that the victors wrote history, but that has not always been the case. This book examines the origins of the war and its progression through two distinct stages. The bleak answer is that for arafat and the palestine liberation organization plo leadership, the oslo process has always been a strategic means not to a twostate solution israel and a palestinian state in the west bank and gaza but to the substitution of a palestinian state for the state of israel.
Between 400 and 600 palestinian villages were sacked during the war. We want to thank both for the courage to present this material. This article appeared august 16, 2010 in middle east forum. Enter efraim karsh, head of mediterranean studies at kings college london, and his latest book, palestine betrayed. Ephraim karshs palestine betrayed tells in rich detail the story of the fall of the british mandate and the rise of israel, going a long way towards doing justice to the history at hand. Click download or read online button to palestine betrayed book pdf for free now. The case for arabisraeli normalization during conflict. In his 2010 book palestine betrayed, followed by a 2011 editorial in haaretz, karsh articulated. The core theme of the book is that regional factors and actors rather than great political powers have played a primary role in the. Blogging about israel and the arab world since, oh, forever.
Ruling palestine, a history of the legally sanctioned jewishisraeli seizure of land and housing in palestine. Apr 27, 2010 karsh referred also to balfour declaration november 1917. In this brave and groundbreaking book, efraim karsh tells the story from both the arab and jewish perspectives. A preeminent historian on the arabisraeli conflict, karsh sets out to reclaim the historical truth behind israels creation. Karsh s 2010 book palestine betrayed is about the breakdown of relations between the jewish and arab communities between 1920 and 1948. It is much easier to pose as a victim, especially as part of a more general arab inferiority complex, and to exploit the mentality of victimhood than to take responsibility for ones own actions. On january 2, 2015, the state of palestine acceded to the rome statute, the iccs founding treaty, and two weeks later, the court opened a preliminary examination into the situation in palestine, having received jurisdiction over alleged crimes committed in the occupied palestinian territory, including east jerusalem, since june, 2014. The 1948 palestinian exodus, also known as the nakba arabic. I consider this latest of karshs books, palestine betrayed, a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with the greatest seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of view indeed, any student of modern israel will. Howard sachar, author of a history of israel, calls it a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with great seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of view. He was head of the middle east and mediterranean studies program at kings college, university of london for some 16 years. History until the late 19th century sovereign jewish state during ancient times for more than years. Proving that for 90 years the palestinian political elite has opted to reject the jewish national revival and insisted on the need for its violent destruction, karsh correctly concludes that the conflict will end only when the.
The myth of palestinian centrality beginsadat center. Why the oslo process doomed peace middle east quarterly. Palestine betrayed by efraim karsh nook book ebook. Palestine betrayed reframes todays arabisraeli debate by putting it into its proper historical context.
European misreading of the israelipalestinian conflict. I consider this latest of karshs books, palestine betrayed, a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with the greatest seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of. This course examines how and with what consequences british interests at the time of the first world war identified and pursued control over palestine, the subsequent forms such projections took, the crises which followed and their eventual consequences. Rethinking the middle east runs counter to the received wisdom in modern middle east studies. Its origins, and that of the wider arabisraeli conflict, are deeplyrooted in jewisharab confrontation and. Efraim karsh director of the beginsadat center for strategic studies. The true story may 8, 2008 sixty years after its establishment by an internationally recognized act of selfdetermination, israel. Kumaraswamy, eds find, read and cite all the research you need on. Professor efraim karsh is a leading historian of the middle east.
Though issued by a european power offering a noneuropean territory, it is also true that the declaration viewed the establishment of a national home for the jewish people in palestine and not of palestine. Ephraim karshs palestine betrayed tells in rich detail the story of the fall of the british. Tuomiojas views are representative of a deeper undercurrent in contemporary european criticism of israel, one that combines factual ignorance and misconceptions about the arab. Palestine betrayed is a detailed riposte to the version of the israelpalestine conflict that places the blame solely at israels doorstep. With isaiah friedman, efraim karsh is the preeminent scholarspokesman of the revisionist politicallyrightist movement in zionism. Karsh is an israelibritish historian, the founding director and emeritus professor of middle east and mediterranean studies at kings college london. I consider this latest of karsh s books, palestine betrayed, a work of meticulous, even exhaustive scholarship which must be taken with the greatest seriousness and respect by historians of diverse points of view. Aug 30, 2010 karshs condescending and with a high probability, erroneous remarks that the new historians were totally unfamiliar with the arab world its language, culture, history, and politics and their condescending treatment of the palestinians as passive objects. His books include arafats war and palestine betrayed. Request pdf on apr 1, 2009, elsayed elaswad and others published islamic attitudes to israel. May 17, 2010 palestine betrayed reframes todays arabisraeli debate by putting it into its proper historical context. Jun 16, 2010 blogging about israel and the arab world since, oh, forever. Palestine betrayed kindle edition by karsh, efraim. Since 20, he serves as professor of political studies at barilan university where he also directs the beginsadat center for strategic studies.
338 129 364 111 142 429 788 1052 1090 1579 1508 329 1321 1047 1380 1430 1580 896 1334 833 1101 241 105 698 637 183 1054 450 244 1515 570 519 1188 778 1185 415 786 128 729 164 30